---
title: "\"Fighting Each Other During War\": Expert Names Main Problem of Ukrainian Law Enforcement Agencies"
description: "Military expert Oleksandr Babak stated that the conflict between Ukraine's law enforcement agencies requires political resolution and the creation of a transparent investigative commission with public participation."
date: 2026-11-15T17:22:35.339Z
lang: en
url: https://xab.info/en/posts/conflict-between-law-enforcement-agencies-ukraine
tags: [ukraine, security-services, law-enforcement, parliament, investigation, carthage-case]
author: "Alexander Buran, Andrey Kosynko"
publisher: "XAB.info"
---

# "Fighting Each Other During War": Expert Names Main Problem of Ukrainian Law Enforcement Agencies

![Armed personnel in black uniforms and balaclavas with SBI markings on tactical vests](https://xab.info/media/2026/11/15/napryazhennost-mezhdu-silovymi-vedomstvami-ukraina/napryazhennost-mezhdu-silovymi-vedomstvami-ukraina-1.webp)

## Key Points

- Babak called the conflict between security agencies the main problem requiring a political solution.
- The expert proposed creating a VR temporary investigative commission involving all factions and public representatives.
- The problem of public detentions, after which cases are quietly closed, was highlighted separately.
- The context of the discussion is the "Carthage" case and new audio recordings by NABU and SAP.

Against the backdrop of high-profile statements by General Serhiy Duka made during a speech near the Lukyanivske Pre-Trial Detention Center, military and political expert Oleksandr Babak outlined a key problem that, in his opinion, needs to be resolved at the political level. This is reported by RBC-Ukraine with reference to Babak's publication on Facebook.

### Briefing Signals and Call for a Transparent Investigation

Commenting on Duka's speech, Babak noted that the briefing "was saturated with sharp and very interesting signals." According to him, each of the presented facts "certainly deserves study and a public report on the results of consideration," and ideally — "a transparent investigation." The expert emphasized that the voiced statements should not be left without proper attention and it should not be expected that the conflict will fade away on its own.

### Main Message — Conflict Within Security Structures

Babak's central thesis was an assessment of tense relations between law enforcement agencies in Ukraine. "For me, the main message is that the problem of tense relations between law enforcement agencies in Ukraine needs to be solved. Because it is akin to absurdity when Ukrainian law enforcement agencies are fighting each other during a war," the expert stated. He indicated that resolving this conflict requires political intervention.

### Mechanism for Resolution — Temporary Investigatory Commission

Babak named the creation of a Verkhovna Rada temporary investigatory commission, the need for which Duka spoke about earlier, as one of the possible tools. In the expert's conviction, the commission should include representatives of all parliamentary factions, including opposition ones. Taking into account, as he says, the low level of public trust in parliament, Babak also proposes involving public representatives — veterans, authoritative military personnel with combat experience, and criminal procedural law specialists.

### Transparency and the Problem of "Show Detentions"

The expert emphasized that the results of the investigation must be convincing to the public, and the process itself must be transparent. Separately, he drew attention to the practice of public detentions and criminal proceedings, which are accompanied by wide publicity but subsequently receive no logical conclusion. "Most of all, society is annoyed by stories when a detention is turned into a show, and a few months later the case is quietly closed," Babak noted, adding that the law enforcement and judicial systems should focus not on the public effect of high-profile cases, but on bringing them to a lawful result.

### Context: The "Carthage" Case and New Audio Recordings

Recall that NABU and SAP previously published new audio recordings in the high-profile "Carthage" case. The agencies announced the exposure of the activities of a criminal organization that, according to them, functioned for years in Ukraine under the cover of SBU, Prosecutor General's Office, and National Police officials. It is against this background, according to experts' assessment, that the discussion about mutual distrust within the security structures is escalating.

## Fact-Check & Sources

- [Проблему напряжения между силовыми ведомствами нужно решать, - военный эксперт](https://www.rbc.ua/ukr/news/problemu-napruzhennya-mizh-silovimi-vidomstvami-1794757153.html) - Babak's quotes, his proposals on the composition of the commission, and the context of the "Carthage" case correspond to the text of the original source.

## FAQ

### Who spoke about the problem of relations between security agencies?

Military and political expert Oleksandr Babak in a commentary published on Facebook and quoted by RBC-Ukraine.

### What settlement mechanism did the expert propose?

The creation of a Verkhovna Rada temporary investigative commission involving representatives of all factions, including the opposition, as well as veterans, combat-experienced military personnel, and criminal procedure specialists.

### What does the expert consider the main irritant for society?

Public "show detentions," after which criminal cases are quietly closed without a legal outcome.