---
title: "First Onions or Carrots: Culinary Experts Explain the Correct Sautéing Order for Borscht and Soups"
description: "Culinary publications The Kitchn and Great British Chefs explain the proper sequence for sautéing onions and carrots: the classic method is onions for 2–4 minutes, then carrots for 4–6 minutes, though the Italian tradition involves cooking them together."
date: 2026-11-22T18:02:08.717Z
lang: en
url: https://xab.info/en/posts/correct-saute-order-onions-carrots-soup
tags: [cooking, borscht, recipe, onions, carrots, soup, frying]
author: "Marina Slivenko, Inna Kinsheva"
publisher: "XAB.info"
---

# First Onions or Carrots: Culinary Experts Explain the Correct Sautéing Order for Borscht and Soups

![Woman in an apron sautéing onions and grated carrots in a pan in a kitchen](https://xab.info/media/2026/11/22/poryadok-zharki-luk-morkov-borsh-sup/poryadok-zharki-luk-morkov-borsh-sup-1.webp)

## Key Points

- According to The Kitchn, onions should be sautéed first for 2–4 minutes until translucent, followed by carrots for 4–6 minutes
- Great British Chefs notes that in Italian cuisine, onions and carrots can be sautéed simultaneously over low heat
- Common mistakes include too high heat, an overcrowded pan, and insufficient stirring of the vegetables

The flavor of borscht, cabbage soup, or any other soup is largely determined by the quality of the vegetable base (zazharka). It provides the aromatic foundation of the dish, yet not all home cooks know the correct sequence for adding vegetables to the pan. The culinary publication The Kitchn recommends starting with onions, as they need time to soften and lose their characteristic sharpness. As they sauté, onions become translucent and their flavor mellows. Allowing them to brown slightly gives the base a more pronounced and deep aroma.

### Step-by-Step Order: Onions First, Then Carrots

Once the onions reach the desired stage of doneness, carrots are added. They soften gradually, and their natural sweetness complements and balances the flavor of the onions. Experts emphasize the importance of preventing the vegetables from burning, as this imparts an undesirable bitterness to the finished dish. For a medium-sized pot of soup, one onion and one carrot are usually sufficient, though proportions can be adjusted based on the recipe. Dice the onions finely, and grate the carrots on a coarse grater or cut them into thin strips. Pour one to two tablespoons of oil into a frying pan and heat over medium heat. Sauté the onions for two to four minutes, stirring occasionally, until soft and translucent. Then add the carrots and cook for another four to six minutes. If you are making borscht, you can add tomato paste or chopped tomatoes at this stage and heat the mixture for a few minutes.

### The Italian Tradition: Cooking Vegetables Together

However, there is no strict rule stating that carrots must always be added only after onions. The publication Great British Chefs notes that in Italian cuisine, onions and carrots are often sautéed simultaneously over low heat, gradually bringing the vegetables to softness and fragrance. If the vegetables are finely chopped, it is entirely acceptable to cook them together. If the carrots are cut into larger pieces, they may require more time than the onions, in which case adding them later makes more sense. For a classic home-style base with grated carrots, it is more convenient to sauté the onions first to monitor their cooking progress.

### Three Common Sautéing Mistakes

The first and most common mistake is using too high of a heat. If the pan is overheated, the onions quickly darken and burn, and the carrots may scorch before they have a chance to soften. It is best to cook vegetables over medium or moderately low heat. The second mistake is crowding too many vegetables into a small pan. In this case, moisture evaporates more slowly, and the vegetables end up stewing rather than frying. To ensure even cooking, it is recommended to use a sufficiently wide pan. The third mistake is insufficient stirring. Onions and carrots heat unevenly, so they need to be stirred periodically, especially near the end of cooking. Following these simple rules ensures an aromatic, evenly cooked vegetable base that makes any soup or borscht truly delicious.

## Fact-Check & Sources

- [Зажарка на борщ и супы: что класть в сковороду первым - морковь или лук](https://styler.rbc.ua/ukr/useful/zasmazhka-borshch-i-supi-shcho-klasti-patelni-1795349628.html) - Primary source. References to The Kitchn and Great British Chefs as expert culinary publications. Facts regarding cooking times, proportions, and mistakes are presented consistently and do not contradict generally accepted culinary practices.

## FAQ

### What should go into the pan first — onions or carrots?

According to The Kitchn, onions go in first and are sautéed for 2–4 minutes until translucent, followed by carrots. However, Great British Chefs notes that in Italian cuisine, it is acceptable to sauté the vegetables simultaneously over low heat.

### How long does it take to sauté onions and carrots?

Onions are sautéed for about 2–4 minutes over medium heat until soft and translucent. Carrots are added to the onions and cooked for another 4–6 minutes until softened, without burning.

### What are the main mistakes when making a vegetable base?

Three frequent mistakes are using too high heat (vegetables burn), crowding too many vegetables in a small pan (they stew instead of fry), and insufficient stirring (uneven heating).

### What proportions of onions and carrots should be used for soup?

For a medium-sized pot of soup, one onion and one carrot are usually enough. Proportions can be adjusted according to the specific recipe.