---
title: "Duka at the TIC: Cases Against NABU Leadership, Malyuk's Order, and New Details of Operation \"Carthage\""
description: "At a TIC meeting, SBU General Serhii Duka spoke about cases against the leadership of NABU and SAP, Malyuk's order to halt actions, and new circumstances of Operation \"Carthage\"."
date: 2026-11-19T00:24:39.288Z
lang: en
url: https://xab.info/en/posts/duka-tic-nabu-sap-carthage
tags: [ukraine-war, sbu, nabu, sap, serhiy-duka, carthage-operation, vsk]
author: "Alexander Buran"
publisher: "XAB.info"
---

# Duka at the TIC: Cases Against NABU Leadership, Malyuk's Order, and New Details of Operation "Carthage"

![SBU General Serhii Duka speaks at a parliamentary commission meeting in front of microphones](https://xab.info/media/2026/11/19/duka-vsk-nabu-sap-kartagen/duka-vsk-nabu-sap-kartagen-1.webp)

## Key Points

- Duka stated that the SBU handled cases against the NABU leadership, and Malyuk ordered a halt to active actions regarding them in autumn 2025.
- The general reported documented corrupt arrangements, as he claims, in the Sambir mayor's case involving a law firm where the SAP head's wife works.
- In the "Carthage" case, Duka denies involvement and claims NABU detectives never interrogated him; investigative bodies, meanwhile, suspect him of participating in a criminal organization.
- Duka confirmed the destruction of two smartphones to protect agent networks and state secrets, and denied a number of accusations against him.
- The next TIC meeting is scheduled for November 23 with the heads of anti-corruption agencies invited.

On November 18, SBU General Serhii Duka spoke at a meeting of the parliamentary Temporary Inquiry Commission (TIC), outlining his position on a number of high-profile criminal proceedings. According to him, the discussions covered investigations concerning the leadership of NABU and SAP, potential political interference in criminal cases, and new circumstances surrounding Operation "Carthage". The broadcast of the meeting and Duka's key statements were reported by RBC-Ukraine. The speech came against the backdrop of the general himself featuring in the "Carthage" case, with a court ordering him on November 6 to be held in custody with the option of posting a 65 million hryvnia bail; the bail was posted last week, and Duka was released from the pre-trial detention center.

### Cases Against NABU Leadership and Malyuk's Order

According to Duka, his unit handled materials regarding the possible fictitious establishment of paternity by NABU Director Semen Kryvonos — allegedly to evade responsibility for vote buying — as well as a land case in Obukhiv. The general stated that in the autumn of 2025, then-SBU Head Vasyl Malyuk ordered a halt to active actions in cases concerning NABU detectives and the Bureau's director. He claimed that materials for issuing a notice of suspicion were prepared at the end of 2025, but the decision was delayed; then-Prosecutor General Ruslan Kravchenko, Duka asserted, explained this by the absence of a political decision.

### SAP Head's Inner Circle and Seizure of Materials

Duka also reported that the SBU documented possible corrupt arrangements in the case of the mayor of Sambir. According to him, an episode involving the transfer of 10,000 dollars featured a law firm where the wife of SAP Head Oleksandr Klymenko works. Separately, the general spoke about NABU detectives seizing an analytical report of the NABU and SAP leadership during a search in Mariia Vdovychenko's office and suggested that this could have created a risk of information leakage to suspects in criminal proceedings.

### Operation "Carthage" and Cooperation with Osypov

Commenting on Operation "Carthage", Duka stated that NABU detectives have never once interrogated him, despite the information campaign and the notice of suspicion. The general explained his cooperation with Andrii Osypov by operational tasks related to the FSB and criminal groups. He denied involvement in covering up Burkina's drug business and recalled sanctions initiated by his unit in 2023. He also questioned the role of NABU detective Mahamedrasulov in the investigation of the "Midas" case and declared attempts at his media "heroization".

### Destruction of Smartphones and Denials

Duka confirmed that he destroyed two smartphones, explaining this by the need to protect agent networks and state secrets. He also spoke about detectives breaking into a house where the security personnel of the "Alpha" unit were located. The general denied accusations of illegal access to registers, the use of the call sign "Akim", and the dissemination of correspondence attributed to him.

### Pressure on Authorities and Khrystenko's Contacts

According to Duka, the leadership of NABU and SAP uses criminal proceedings and information campaigns as instruments of influence on the authorities, while he denied the existence of an institutional conflict between the SBU and anti-corruption agencies. The general called the dissemination of information about a possible suspicion against President's Office Head Kyrylo Budanov an attempt at political pressure and accused anti-corruption agencies and a number of media outlets of exerting pressure on President Volodymyr Zelenskyy, destabilizing the situation, and weakening Ukraine's negotiating positions. Separately, he raised the issue of contacts between former MP Fedir Khrystenko, convicted of high treason, and the SAP leadership, noting that some of the relevant materials are classified.

### Polygraph and the Next TIC Meeting

Duka stated that over the course of a year, not a single NABU employee underwent a polygraph test under the new procedure because the Bureau did not coordinate the methodology with the SBU; the TIC instructed to verify compliance with the legislation. Context reminder: within the framework of the "Carthage" case, NABU and SAP suspect Duka of involvement in a criminal organization that, according to the investigation, covered up illegal businesses, in particular a network of fraudulent call centers and a drug cartel. The next TIC meeting is scheduled for November 23; the heads of anti-corruption agencies and former officials of the law enforcement system have been invited to discuss the circumstances of the high-profile investigation.

## Accounts differ

### Serhii Duka's involvement in the "Carthage" case

- **Serhii Duka (SBU General):** Denies involvement in a criminal organization and covering up the drug business, claims NABU detectives never interrogated him, and states that cooperation with Osypov was linked to operational tasks. ([rbc.ua](https://www.rbc.ua/ukr/news/vid-sprav-shchodo-kerivnitstva-nabu-detaley-1795029993.html))
- **NABU and SAP:** Suspect Duka of involvement in a criminal organization that, according to the investigation, covered up illegal businesses, specifically a network of fraudulent call centers and a drug cartel. ([rbc.ua](https://www.rbc.ua/ukr/news/vid-sprav-shchodo-kerivnitstva-nabu-detaley-1795029993.html))

*Where they agree:* Duka features in the "Carthage" case, was notified of suspicion, and spoke at the TIC meeting on November 18.

## Fact-Check & Sources

- [От дел по руководству НАБУ до деталей "Карфагена": о чем говорил Дука на ВСК](https://www.rbc.ua/ukr/news/vid-sprav-shchodo-kerivnitstva-nabu-detaley-1795029993.html) - Primary source: the text of Duka's speech at the TIC on November 18 via the broadcast of the meeting; contains all key statements used in the article, as well as context about the pre-trial restriction (65 mln UAH bail) and the date of the next meeting (November 23).

## FAQ

### When and where did Serhii Duka speak?

On November 18 at a meeting of the parliamentary Temporary Inquiry Commission (TIC).

### What did Duka state regarding the "Carthage" case?

He denies involvement in a criminal organization, claims NABU detectives never interrogated him, and explains cooperation with Osypov by operational tasks. NABU and SAP, by contrast, suspect him of participating in an organization that covered up illegal businesses.

### What pre-trial restriction was chosen for Duka?

On November 6, a court ordered custody with the option of posting a 65 million hryvnia bail; the bail was posted last week, and he was released from the pre-trial detention center.

### When is the next TIC meeting?

November 23; the heads of anti-corruption agencies and former law enforcement officials have been invited.