---
title: "Personnel Shortages and Underfunding: Experts Identify Systemic Problems at the Economic Security Bureau"
description: "Oleg Getman of the Economic Expert Platform stated that the ESB is working with a shortfall of nearly 3,000 employees, salaries 1.5 times lower than NABU, and no income tax reimbursement. Meanwhile, in November 2026, the bureau began analytical cooperation with the Ministry of Defense."
date: 2026-11-17T10:54:33.750Z
lang: en
url: https://xab.info/en/posts/esb-personnel-shortages-and-underfunding-problems
tags: [ukraine, economic-security, beb, law-enforcement, staffing, underfunding, apple-seizure, ministry-of-defense]
author: "Alexander Buran"
publisher: "XAB.info"
---

# Personnel Shortages and Underfunding: Experts Identify Systemic Problems at the Economic Security Bureau

![Emblem of the Economic Security Bureau of Ukraine on a grey uniform sleeve](https://xab.info/media/2026/11/17/beb-kadrovyy-golod-i-nedofinansirovanie-problemy-byuro-ekonomicheskoy-bezopasnosti/beb-kadrovyy-golod-i-nedofinansirovanie-problemy-byuro-ekonomicheskoy-bezopasnosti-1.webp)

## Key Points

- ESB staff is 1,100 people compared to the need for 4,000; territorial branches are open in only 10 regions
- ESB salaries are 1.5 times lower than NABU/SAP; income tax is not reimbursed
- Only 200 out of 1,000 employees have completed re-certification due to a 12-member commission
- In the first 10 months of 2026, the ESB seized 376 million hryvnia worth of equipment from the shadow market, 74% were Apple products
- In November 2026, the ESB began analytical cooperation with the Ministry of Defense to verify defense procurements

The Economic Security Bureau (ESB) of Ukraine, established in 2021 to investigate economic crimes, is facing a complex set of systemic issues: a critical staff shortage, underfunding, and slow staff re-certification. This was stated by Oleg Getman, coordinator of the expert groups at the Economic Expert Platform, during the forum "Dialogue Between Government, Civil Society, and Business: Economic Resilience and Competitiveness," organized by the Ukrainian Business Council, CIPE, and Economic Expert. According to him, the state demands investigation results from the ESB but fails to provide the agency with the resources necessary for full-scale operation.

### Personnel Shortage: 1,100 Employees Instead of 4,000

The main problem of the ESB, pointed out by Getman, is a catastrophic lack of personnel. Currently, the bureau employs 1,100 people, while the required staffing level should be 4,000, or 2,500 at a minimum. Territorial branches are open in only 10 regions, making it impossible for the agency to have a full presence across the country. "They are not given the budget to be present in all regions," the expert emphasized. Thus, the ESB effectively cannot perform its functions on the scale envisioned at its inception.

### Salary Gap and Staff Turnover

The average salary of ESB employees is 1.5 times lower than in similar law enforcement agencies, such as the National Anti-Corruption Bureau (NABU) and the Specialized Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office (SAP). This creates direct competition for qualified specialists: "Their best workers are taken by NABU," Getman noted. Furthermore, unlike most other law enforcement agencies, where employees are reimbursed for the personal income tax paid (18%), ESB staff do not receive such compensation. The combination of these factors creates unfavorable working conditions and accelerates staff turnover within the agency.

### Re-certification: 800 out of 1,000 Yet to Be Verified

An additional obstacle to the effective operation of the ESB is the slow re-certification process that all bureau employees must undergo. The commission conducting the procedure consists of only 12 people, which objectively limits capacity. According to Getman, out of 1,000 employees, only 200 have completed re-certification, while 800 are still waiting for their turn. This means that a significant portion of the staff cannot formally be cleared for full operational activities until the procedure is completed.

### Performance Results: 376 Million Hryvnia Seized from the Shadow Market

Despite the difficulties described, the ESB is showing certain results. Over the first 10 months of 2026, the bureau seized products worth nearly 376 million hryvnia from the shadow market of technology and electronics. Notably, nearly 74% of the total volume — 75.4 thousand devices and accessories — consisted of Apple products: iPhones, MacBooks, iPads, Apple Watches, and AirPods. This demonstrates that even with limited resources, the agency is capable of conducting targeted work to identify the illegal trade of expensive equipment.

### New Direction: Cooperation with the Ministry of Defense

In November 2026, the ESB began cooperating with the Ministry of Defense of Ukraine to prevent economic violations and corruption schemes in the defense sector. Upon the request of the Ministry of Defense, the bureau's analysts will examine market price offers, check the real owners of companies participating in and winning public procurements, and assess potential risks. This expansion of the mandate, against the backdrop of staff shortages, presents the ESB with even more ambitious tasks, the resolution of which, according to experts, is impossible without increasing funding and staffing.

## Fact-Check & Sources

- [Недостает почти 3 тысяч работников: эксперт назвал главные проблемы БЭБ](https://www.rbc.ua/ukr/news/brakue-mayzhe-3-tisyachi-pratsivnikiv-ekspert-1794912343.html) - Quote from Oleg Getman at the 'Dialogue Between Government, Civil Society, and Business' forum. All figures (1100/4000/2500 employees, 10 regions, 1.5x salary, 12 commission members, 200/800 re-certification, 376 million UAH, 75.4k Apple devices) are provided in the source text.

## FAQ

### When was the Economic Security Bureau established?

The ESB was created in 2021. In November of the same year, the Cabinet of Ministers launched the agency, which replaced the liquidated tax police and took over the authority to investigate economic crimes from the SBU.

### How many employees work at the ESB now, and how many should there be?

According to Oleg Getman, the ESB has 1,100 employees, while the staffing level should be 4,000, or a minimum of 2,500.

### What are the results of the ESB's work for 2026?

During the first 10 months of 2026, the ESB seized technology and electronics worth nearly 376 million hryvnia from the shadow market. 74% of the volume (75,400 devices) consisted of Apple smartphones, laptops, tablets, watches, and headphones.

### What does the cooperation between the ESB and the Ministry of Defense entail?

In November 2026, the ESB began analytical cooperation with the Ministry of Defense: at the request of the agency, analysts examine market price offers, check the actual owners of bidding companies, and evaluate potential risks of corruption schemes in the defense sector.