---
title: "Fidan: Russia not ready for Black Sea truce without long-term peace with Ukraine — it all comes down to Donbas"
description: "Turkish Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan stated that Russia is not ready for a temporary Black Sea truce without long-term peace with Ukraine, with the issue of Donbas remaining the key obstacle."
date: 2026-11-17T03:04:19.795Z
lang: en
url: https://xab.info/en/posts/fidan-russia-not-ready-black-sea-truce
tags: [turkey, hakan-fidan, black-sea-ceasefire, donbas, ukraine-russia, peace-negotiations, european-security]
author: "Andrey Kosynko"
publisher: "XAB.info"
---

# Fidan: Russia not ready for Black Sea truce without long-term peace with Ukraine — it all comes down to Donbas

![Turkish Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan makes statements regarding the settlement of the conflict in Ukraine](https://xab.info/media/2026/11/17/fidan-rossiya-ne-gotova-k-peremiriyu-v-chyornom-more-bez-dolgosrochnogo-mira/fidan-rossiya-ne-gotova-k-peremiriyu-v-chyornom-more-bez-dolgosrochnogo-mira-1.webp)

## Key Points

- Fidan stated that Russia does not want a temporary Black Sea agreement without a long-term peace settlement with Ukraine
- The minister called the issue of Donbas the key obstacle to a truce: Russia demands its transfer, Ukraine refuses
- According to Russian estimates, the dispute concerns 11–12% of the territory; according to Ukrainian estimates, it is 18%
- Turkey has its own ideas on Europe's security architecture, but does not yet disclose details

Turkish Foreign Minister Hakan Fidan stated in a comment to TRT Haber that Moscow is not interested in concluding a temporary Black Sea agreement unless it is linked to a long-term peace settlement between Russia and Ukraine. According to the Turkish diplomat, this exact stance by the Russian side is the main brake on achieving even a partial cessation of hostilities in the region. Fidan emphasized that Ankara has its own ideas on creating a basis for mutual understanding between the parties, though he added that «it is still too early to share them with the public».

### Donbas as the Central Obstacle

The Turkish Foreign Minister directly pointed out that the entire essence of the problem regarding a truce in the Black Sea and, more broadly, ending the war boils down to the status of Donbas. «Russia demands that it be given up, while Ukraine says it will not do this,» Fidan stated. According to him, this very issue is the reason for the continuation of hostilities. At the same time, the minister cited two different assessments of the scale of the territorial dispute: according to Russian calculations, it concerns the remaining 11–12% of the territory, whereas according to Ukrainian estimates, it is 18%.

### Ceasefire Line and Security Guarantees

Fidan explained that after a peace agreement is concluded between Kyiv and Moscow, it will be necessary to seriously work out where exactly the ceasefire line will run. Only after that, he said, can discussions move on to security guarantees and the overall security architecture in Europe. «Peace between Ukraine and Russia will be peace not only between these two countries. It will also be peace between Europe and Russia,» the Turkish Foreign Minister stressed, adding that Ankara holds «very serious considerations» regarding the new security architecture on the continent.

### Context: Energy Truce and Sanctions

Fidan's statements came amid ongoing discussions about a potential sectoral truce. Earlier, according to American and Ukrainian officials briefed on the talks, Moscow demanded the lifting or easing of U.S. sanctions in exchange for approving a truce in the energy sector, while simultaneously trying to tie this initiative to a Black Sea truce. Publicly, however, the Russian side has shown no readiness for such agreements: Kremlin Spokesperson Dmitry Peskov stated on October 8 that Moscow «sees no point» in talks on a sectoral truce, calling the energy sector Ukraine's «Achilles' heel». Thus, the position voiced by Fidan — linking any partial agreement to a comprehensive peace — aligns with the Kremlin's public rhetoric.

### What's Next: The Complexity of a Multilateral Deal

Fidan acknowledged that reaching an agreement on all issues in a way that suits all parties is «quite difficult». According to him, the content of the discussed agreement includes a whole range of points — from the demarcation line to security guarantees and the architecture of peace in Europe. «While this work is ongoing, we are also dealing with other issues. Perhaps everything will work out, and I hope it will. After all, it is important to achieve a final end to the war,» the Turkish Foreign Minister summarized. Fidan's statement, broadcast via TRT Haber and quoted by RBC-Ukraine, became one of the most detailed public assessments of the peace process by Turkish diplomacy in recent times.

## Accounts differ

### Volume of territory that became the subject of the territorial dispute

- **Russia (according to the estimate cited by Fidan):** It concerns the remaining 11–12% of the territory ([rbc.ua](https://www.rbc.ua/ukr/news/rosiya-hoche-ukladati-peremir-ya-chornomu-1794884325.html))
- **Ukraine (according to the estimate cited by Fidan):** It concerns 18% of the territory ([rbc.ua](https://www.rbc.ua/ukr/news/rosiya-hoche-ukladati-peremir-ya-chornomu-1794884325.html))

*Where they agree:* Both sides recognize that the issue of Donbas is the central obstacle to concluding a truce and ending the war

## Fact-Check & Sources

- [Россия не хочет заключать перемирие в Черном море без полной мирной сделки, - Фидан](https://www.rbc.ua/ukr/news/rosiya-hoche-ukladati-peremir-ya-chornomu-1794884325.html) - Primary source: direct quotes from Fidan's TRT Haber commentary. All key points of the article (Russia's position on the Black Sea, Donbas as an obstacle, territory percentages, security architecture) are taken from this source.
- [Россия хочет отмены санкций США в обмен на "энергетическое перемирие" – СМИ](https://www.pravda.com.ua/rus/news/2026/10/09/8057222/) - Used as context: Russia's demand for sanctions in exchange for an energy truce, Peskov's statement on October 8. Not the basis of the article's main thesis.
- [Россия требует от США смягчения санкций в обмен на энергетическое перемирие – Kyiv Independent](https://ukranews.com/news/1180192-rossiya-trebuet-ot-ssha-smyagcheniya-sanktsij-v-obmen-na-energeticheskoe-peremirie-kyiv-independent) - Confirms context from source 2: data from American and Ukrainian officials regarding Moscow's position on sanctions and an energy truce.

## FAQ

### What exactly did Fidan say about Russia's position on the Black Sea truce?

According to the Turkish Foreign Minister, Russia does not want to conclude a temporary agreement with Ukraine on the Black Sea without simultaneously concluding a long-term peace agreement. In Fidan's assessment, this is the main brake on a partial cessation of hostilities.

### Which issue did Fidan call the reason for the continuation of the war?

The minister pointed to Donbas: Russia demands that this territory be handed over, while Ukraine refuses. According to Russian estimates, the dispute concerns 11–12% of the territory, while Ukrainian estimates put it at 18%.

### Does Turkey have specific proposals for a settlement?

Fidan stated that Ankara has ideas for creating a basis for mutual understanding between the parties and «very serious considerations» regarding a new European security architecture, but he did not disclose details, noting it is still too early to share them with the public.

### What will be discussed after the conclusion of a peace agreement?

According to Fidan, after a peace agreement, it will be necessary to determine the ceasefire line, then move on to security guarantees and develop a new security architecture in Europe, since peace between Ukraine and Russia will affect all of Europe.