---
title: "Case \"Carthage\": HACC asked to remand \"Criminal\" in custody without bail"
description: "HACC is choosing a preventive measure for Andriy Osypov, a figure in the \"Carthage\" case under the pseudonym \"Criminal\". The SAPO prosecutor is requesting detention without bail due to the risk of flight and witness pressure."
date: 2026-11-18T18:34:49.992Z
lang: en
url: https://xab.info/en/posts/hacc-remands-criminal-carthage-case
tags: [carthage-case, nabu, sap, vak, corruption, ukraine]
author: "Andrey Kosynko"
publisher: "XAB.info"
---

# Case "Carthage": HACC asked to remand "Criminal" in custody without bail

![A person's hands in handcuffs behind prison bars in a dark room](https://xab.info/media/2026/11/18/vak-izbiraet-meru-presecheniya-kriminalu-karfagen/vak-izbiraet-meru-presecheniya-kriminalu-karfagen-1.webp)

## Key Points

- The HACC is choosing a preventive measure for Andriy Osypov, who appears under the pseudonym "Criminal" in NABU recordings.
- The SAPO prosecutor is requesting detention without bail, citing the risk of flight, witness tampering, and destruction of evidence.
- The suspect is charged with participation in a criminal organization, corruption, and legalization of property; some charges carry up to 12 years with confiscation.
- The investigation highlights 37 border crossings, links to former SBU head Malyuk, and refusal to provide phone passwords upon arrest.

On November 18, 2026, the High Anti-Corruption Court (HACC) held a hearing in the "Carthage" case to determine a preventive measure for Andriy Osypov, a person who appears under the pseudonym "Criminal" on NABU and SAPO audio recordings. A prosecutor from the Specialized Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office (SAPO) filed a motion to remand the suspect in custody without the possibility of bail, citing risks of flight, witness tampering, and destruction of evidence. This was reported by RBC-Ukraine with reference to the live stream of the court hearing.

### Prosecution motion and grounds

The SAPO prosecutor requested that the court apply a preventive measure of detention without bail for Osypov. Among the grounds for this motion, the prosecution cited the risk that the figure would flee abroad, pressure witnesses and other suspects, and the likelihood of destroying or tampering with evidence.

### Charges and potential sentences

According to the prosecutor, the suspect is charged with a number of serious and particularly serious criminal offenses, including participation in a criminal organization, corruption, and legalization of property. Some of the charges carry a potential sentence of up to 12 years in prison with asset forfeiture.

### Foreign passport and 37 border crossings

The prosecution drew the court's attention to the fact that Osypov has a foreign passport and, according to the investigation, has crossed the state border of Ukraine 37 times, spending a total of about 300 days abroad.

### Links to the former head of the SBU and law enforcement officials

Separately, the prosecutor recalled the suspect's ties to former SBU head Vasyl Malyuk and other law enforcement officials, including Serhiy Duka and Rubel. According to the prosecution, the suspect could use these contacts to evade investigation or illegally influence the participants in the criminal proceedings.

### Covert investigative actions and refusal to provide passwords

The prosecutor also referred to materials from covert investigative (search) actions, which recorded the suspect's conversations with law enforcement officials, as well as correspondence regarding searches at a call center in Odesa and the return of seized equipment. An additional argument for the prosecution was Osypov's refusal to provide passwords to his mobile phones during his arrest, which the investigation links to the risk of destroying evidence.

### Context: what is known about the "Carthage" case

As a reminder, on November 4, 2026, NABU and SAPO released new audio recordings in the case. According to law enforcement, the group included at least 12 people, including current officials of the SBU, the Prosecutor General's Office, and the National Police. Previously, preventive measures were chosen for other defendants in the case: SBU Major General Serhiy Duka was released from the detention center after posting bail of 65 million hryvnias; the court ordered lawyer Oleksandr Didych, whom SAPO calls a "trusted agent" of Serhiy Kropyva, to be held in custody until November 2 or post bail of 15 million hryvnias; Kropyva's partner Yelizaveta Ivakhnenko, appearing in the materials under the pseudonym "Muse", was ordered to be detained with the right to post bail of 20 million hryvnias.

## Fact-Check & Sources

- [Дело "Карфаген": суд избирает меру пресечения "Криминалу"](https://www.rbc.ua/ukr/news/sprava-karfagen-sud-obirae-zapobizhniy-zahid-1795000233.html) - Source: SAPO prosecutor's motion for detention without bail, grounds, charges, 37 border crossings, links to Malyuk/Duka, covert actions, refusal of passwords, Nov 4 recordings, Duka bail 65 million UAH.
- [Дело "Карфаген": меру пресечения получил адвокат, которого САП называет "доверенным лицом" Кропивы](https://news.liga.net/politics/news/delo-karfagen-meru-presecheniya-poluchil-advokat-kotorogo-sap-nazyvaet-doverennym-litsom-kropivy) - Контекст: мера пресечения адвокату Александру Дидичу — стража до 2 ноября либо залог 15 млн грн; статус «доверенного лица» Сергея Кропивы.
- [Дело "Карфаген": ВАКС избрал меру пресечения для "Музы" Елизаветы Ивахненко](https://focus.ua/ukraine/766912-muza-po-delu-karfagen-elizaveta-ivahnenko-arestovana-s-zalogom-v-20-mln-grn) - Контекст: Ивахненко («Муза») — стража до 2 ноября 2026 с правом залога 20 млн грн; сожительница Сергея Кропивы.
- ["Муза" в СИЗО: суд арестовал фигурантку дела «Карфаген» Елизавету Ивахненко](https://kp.ua/politics/a735632-vaks-arestoval-fihurantku-dela-karfahen-elizaveta-ivakhnenko-s-zalohom-v-20-mln-hrn) - Дополнительный контекст по мере пресечения для Елизаветы Ивахненко, согласуется с источником 3.

## FAQ

### Who is "Criminal" in the "Carthage" case?

This is the pseudonym under which Andriy Osypov appears in NABU and SAPO audio recordings; the HACC held a preventive measure hearing for him on November 18, 2026.

### What preventive measure is the prosecution requesting?

The SAPO prosecutor is requesting that Osypov be remanded in custody without bail, citing the risk of flight abroad, witness tampering, and destruction of evidence.

### What is the suspect charged with and what are the potential sentences?

He is charged with participation in a criminal organization, corruption, and property legalization; some charges carry up to 12 years in prison with asset forfeiture.

### What is known about other figures in the "Carthage" case?

According to law enforcement, the group included at least 12 people, including current SBU, Prosecutor General's Office, and National Police officials. Serhiy Duka posted 65 million UAH bail, lawyer Didych received custody or 15 million UAH bail, and Yelizaveta Ivakhnenko received custody with the right to 20 million UAH bail.