---
title: "Ombudsman: IDPs massively deprived of benefits due to errors in state databases and formalistic approach"
description: "Ombudsman Dmytro Lubinets reported mass refusals of IDP benefits due to state database errors and a formalistic approach. The new IDP law has been in effect since October 22, but bylaws are not ready; the program has been extended until February 2027."
date: 2026-11-15T06:06:34.279Z
lang: en
url: https://xab.info/en/posts/idp-benefits-denied-ombudsman-database-errors
tags: [idp-aid, ukraine-social-policy, ombudsman, displaced-persons, state-benefits]
author: "Alexander Buran, Marina Slivenko"
publisher: "XAB.info"
---

# Ombudsman: IDPs massively deprived of benefits due to errors in state databases and formalistic approach

![A woman with a suitcase sits in a waiting room in front of a service desk](https://xab.info/media/2026/11/15/vpo-otkazy-v-pomoshchi-ombudsman-oshibki-v-gosbazah/vpo-otkazy-v-pomoshchi-ombudsman-oshibki-v-gosbazah-1.webp)

## Key Points

- Ombudsman Lubinets records systemic refusals of IDP benefits due to errors in state databases and formalistic criteria evaluation
- The income threshold for receiving assistance is 10,380 hryvnias per family member; deposits, purchases over 100k UAH, and housing conditions are also taken into account
- The new IDP law came into force on October 22, 2026, but the Ministry of Social Policy did not prepare bylaws; the program was extended until the end of February 2027
- The Rada Budget Committee supported the government instruction to work on increasing payments for displaced persons

Ukrainian Parliament Commissioner for Human Rights Dmytro Lubinets has publicly stated that there are systemic problems in the mechanism for providing state assistance to internally displaced persons (IDPs). According to him, a significant number of displaced persons are refused payments or stripped of previously assigned benefits for reasons that do not reflect the real situation in their families. Among the key factors are erroneous and incomplete data in state information systems, a formalistic assessment of housing conditions, and the calculation of savings accumulated over the years. This is reported by RBC-Ukraine, citing the ombudsman's statement.

### Formal criteria and their consequences for families

The right to receive state assistance for IDPs is tied to a number of quantitative indicators. The central one is the average monthly income per family member, which must not exceed 10,380 hryvnias. In addition to income, social protection authorities take into account the presence of deposits, one-time purchases worth over 100,000 hryvnias, the acquisition of a new car or real estate, the availability of suitable housing, employment status, and whether children are studying. According to Lubinets, it is this set of formal criteria, applied without taking into account the individual circumstances of a specific family, that leads to people who objectively need support being left out of the program.

### Errors in state databases

The ombudsman identified technical and organizational failures in the operation of state information systems as a separate block of problems. In particular, he pointed to cases where border-crossing data is recorded incompletely: the system registers a person's departure from the combat zone but fails to record their return. As a result, the displaced person is formally considered to be outside the territory, which can become grounds for terminating payments. In addition, the databases contain outdated or simply erroneous information about income, property, and housing conditions that does not reflect the actual state of affairs. Lubinets emphasizes that compliance with formal criteria cannot be correctly assessed without clarifying the real circumstances of a family's life.

### Delay in bylaws of the new IDP law

Legislative uncertainty creates an additional risk for displaced persons. The new law on internally displaced persons came into force on October 22, 2026, but the Ministry of Social Policy failed to prepare the necessary bylaws within the established deadlines. Pavlo Frolov, Chairman of the Verkhovna Rada Special Commission on IDP Protection, previously warned that in the absence of approved regulatory documents, displaced persons could be groundlessly removed from the register and deprived of assistance. Until the new mechanisms are launched, payments continue to be made under the previous rules: the assistance program has been extended until the end of February 2027.

### Prospects for increasing payments

Despite existing problems, the position on the need to strengthen support has been established at the level of parliamentary control. The Budget Committee of the Verkhovna Rada supported the instruction to the government to work out the issue of increasing the amount of payments for IDPs. If relevant decisions are made as part of the budget formation, displaced persons can expect higher amounts of assistance starting next year. Nevertheless, according to the ombudsman, without eliminating systemic errors in the data and without moving to an individual assessment of each family's situation, a formal increase in the allowance amount will not solve the problem of unjustified refusals.

## Fact-Check & Sources

- [ВПО незаконно лишают помощи: омбудсман назвал самые распространенные причины](https://www.rbc.ua/ukr/news/vpo-nezakonno-pozbavlyayut-dopomogi-ombudsman-1794721452.html) - Single source. Public statement by Ombudsman Lubinets, transmitted via RBC-Ukraine. Specific figures (10,380 UAH, 100k UAH) and dates (October 22, February 2027) are given in the text. There is no independent cross-confirmation regarding individual cases of refusals in the provided materials.

## FAQ

### What income threshold determines an IDP's right to state assistance?

The average monthly income per family member must not exceed 10,380 hryvnias. In addition to income, deposits, purchases over 100,000 hryvnias, ownership of a new car or real estate, housing conditions, employment, and children's education are taken into account.

### When did the new IDP law come into force and is it ready to operate?

The law came into force on October 22, 2026, but the Ministry of Social Policy did not manage to prepare bylaws. Until they are adopted, assistance is paid under the old rules, and the program has been extended until the end of February 2027.

### What are the main reasons for benefit denials named by the ombudsman?

Dmytro Lubinets points to erroneous and incomplete data in state systems, incorrect recording of border crossings, a formalistic assessment of housing conditions, and the calculation of savings without clarifying the circumstances of a specific family.

### Can payments for displaced persons increase?

The Budget Committee of the Verkhovna Rada supported the government instruction to work out the issue of increasing payments. If a decision is made, amounts may increase starting next year.