---
title: "Xi, Trump and Putin Meeting: Diplomats in Kyiv Call It a 'Bad Precedent' for Ukraine and Europe"
description: "A diplomatic source from RBC-Ukraine called the meeting between Xi Jinping, Trump, and Putin a bad precedent for Ukraine and Europe. Parties differ in their assessment of the agenda: from the war to AI risks."
date: 2026-11-19T05:54:41.695Z
lang: en
url: https://xab.info/en/posts/xi-trump-putin-meeting-bad-precedent
tags: [china-usa-russia-summit, putin-trump-xi, ukraine-war, diplomacy, apec]
author: "Alexander Buran, Andrey Kosynko"
publisher: "XAB.info"
---

# Xi, Trump and Putin Meeting: Diplomats in Kyiv Call It a 'Bad Precedent' for Ukraine and Europe

![Donald Trump, Xi Jinping, and Vladimir Putin at a joint meeting during the APEC summit](https://xab.info/media/2026/11/19/vstrecha-si-trampa-i-putina-plohoi-pretsedent-dlya-ukrainy/vstrecha-si-trampa-i-putina-plohoi-pretsedent-dlya-ukrainy-1.webp)

## Key Points

- A diplomatic source in Kyiv called the trilateral meeting of Xi, Trump, and Putin a bad precedent that could become a practice.
- The greatest concern is sparked by bilateral negotiations, including the talk between Trump and Putin, where the U.S. leader called Putin a friend.
- Xi Jinping, according to the source, will play the role of a moderator without clear positioning, retaining an option for China's involvement in the peace process.
- Publications differ in their assessment of the agenda: WSJ links it to ending the war on Moscow's terms, while SCMP points to AI risks for nuclear weapons.

On the sidelines of the APEC summit, the first-ever trilateral meeting took place between the leaders of Russia, the USA, and China — Vladimir Putin, Donald Trump, and Xi Jinping. According to an informed source in diplomatic circles familiar with Kyiv's position, the very fact of such a format is a "bad precedent for Ukraine and Europe that could become a practice." The biggest concern, according to the RBC-Ukraine source, is not so much the joint photo, but the bilateral negotiations that the leaders held during the same visit.

### "A bad precedent that could become practice"

"We have great concerns about the bilateral meetings. As for the Xi-Trump-Putin format, the very fact of such a meeting is a bad precedent for us and for the Europeans, which could become a regular practice," the source said. According to them, even though China, in Kyiv's assessment, is not seeking open intervention in the settlement, it will be impossible to avoid discussing Ukraine within such a format. Diplomats emphasize: if the three powers regularly gather leaders at one table without the participation of the direct parties to the conflict, this will be established as a stable norm of foreign policy.

### Beijing's Role: A Moderator Without Clear Positioning

According to the same source, Xi Jinping will likely seek to act as a moderator of the discussion, avoiding clear positioning on key issues. "Most likely, the thesis will be voiced that if the negotiations advance, China at a certain stage could consider the possibility of its own involvement in the peace process," believes the RBC-Ukraine source. Thus, Beijing retains an option to participate in the settlement without locking in specific obligations.

### Bilateral Talk Between Trump and Putin

Before the trilateral format, Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin held separate talks. According to Kremlin aide Yuri Ushakov, the leaders discussed the war in Ukraine and bilateral relations. At the beginning of the conversation, the American leader called Putin his friend and expressed hope for a productive meeting. It is these bilateral contacts, rather than the joint photo, that cause, according to the diplomatic source, the greatest concern in Kyiv and European capitals.

### Different Versions of the Agenda

International publications differ on exactly what the main topic of the meeting will be. According to The Wall Street Journal, the idea of a trilateral format was proposed by Putin himself in October to discuss ending the war on terms favorable to Moscow. The South China Morning Post, on the contrary, points out that the risks of artificial intelligence for nuclear weapons could be at the center of the agenda, while the war in Ukraine could take a backseat. In Kyiv, meanwhile, they are waiting for information from Trump's envoys about the results of the negotiations.

### Kyiv's Expectations and Expert Assessment

RBC experts note that the main result of the negotiations could be the very fact of them taking place: the meeting demonstrates the readiness of the three major powers for dialogue. Foreign media emphasize that this is the first trilateral meeting at this level in history and discuss it in the context of a broader architecture — from relations between Russia and Europe to the Taiwan issue and U.S. Latin American policy. In Kyiv, however, they emphasize: until the American administration's envoys announce specific outcomes, any assessments remain preliminary, and the format itself remains a precedent whose consequences are yet to be evaluated.

## Accounts differ

### Main topic and purpose of the trilateral meeting

- **The Wall Street Journal:** The idea for a trilateral meeting was proposed by Putin in October to discuss ending the war on terms favorable to Moscow. ([rbc.ua](https://www.rbc.ua/ukr/news/zustrich-si-trampa-i-putina-mozhe-stati-poganim-1795067307.html))
- **South China Morning Post:** The main topic of the meeting could be the risks of AI to nuclear weapons, while the war in Ukraine could take a back seat. ([rbc.ua](https://www.rbc.ua/ukr/news/zustrich-si-trampa-i-putina-mozhe-stati-poganim-1795067307.html))

*Where they agree:* A meeting of the leaders of Russia, the USA, and China occurred, and the issue of Ukraine is on the agenda, though with varying degrees of priority.

## Fact-Check & Sources

- [Встреча Си, Трампа и Путина может стать плохим прецедентом для Украины, - источник](https://www.rbc.ua/ukr/news/zustrich-si-trampa-i-putina-mozhe-stati-poganim-1795067307.html) - Primary source: quotes from a diplomatic source, assessment of the format, role of Xi, bilateral talk between Trump and Putin, versions from WSJ and SCMP.
- [Эксперты оценили значение встречи Путина, Трампа и Си Цзиньпина](https://www.rbc.ru/politics/19/11/2026/6afe0b9163968b37981d177b) - Expert assessment: the main result might be the very fact of the meeting taking place and the demonstration of readiness for dialogue.
- [России – Европу, Китаю – Тайвань, США – Латинскую Америку. Какой видят встречу Путина, Си и ...](https://19rusinfo.ru/politika/132126-rossii-evropu-kitayu-tajvan-ssha-latinskuyu-ameriku-kakoj-vidyat-vstrechu-putina-si-i-trampa-zarubezhnye-smi) - Points to the first-ever trilateral meeting and its discussion in foreign press; mentions Shenzhen location.
- ["Путин хотел разделить мир, но Трамп и Си не хотят разделить с ним даже обед". Одиночество Путина ...](https://gordonua.com/section-worldnews/news-putyn-khotel-razdelyt-myr-no-tramp-y-sy-ne-khotyat-razdelyt-s-nym-dazhe-obed-odynochestvo-putyna-v-kytae-19-11-2026.html) - Confirms the context of the APEC summit and the joint photo of the leaders, which is consistent with the fact of the meeting.

## FAQ

### Who held the trilateral meeting and when?

As part of the APEC summit, the first-ever trilateral meeting of leaders of Russia, the USA, and China — Vladimir Putin, Donald Trump, and Xi Jinping — took place.

### Why does Kyiv call the meeting a bad precedent?

According to a diplomatic source for RBC-Ukraine, the format of the meeting itself, without Ukraine's participation, creates a precedent that could become a practice, with the leaders' bilateral talks causing the greatest concern.

### What role is assigned to China?

Xi Jinping, according to the source, will play the role of a moderator without clear positioning and may voice China's readiness to consider its own involvement in the peace process at a certain stage.

### How do assessments of the agenda differ?

The Wall Street Journal links the initiative to discussing the end of the war on Moscow's terms, while the South China Morning Post points to AI risks for nuclear weapons as a potential main topic, potentially pushing the war in Ukraine to the background.