A group of experts led by Michael Freeman, editor-in-chief of the Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine and a fellow of the Royal College of Pathologists, has challenged the official ruling on the death of financier Jeffrey Epstein. Accused of sex trafficking, Epstein died in a New York City jail cell in August 2019; his death was officially ruled a suicide. Freeman's team now asserts that Epstein was murdered. Their assessment is based on several months of analysis of previously unpublished autopsy photos and materials provided to the researchers by Epstein's brother.
How the case was reviewed
The work was led by Michael Freeman, who specializes in injury analysis and the circumstances of deaths in custody, as well as the application of epidemiological methods in forensics. He was assisted by Itiel Dror, a professor at Sweden's Örebro University and a cognitive neuroscientist studying the impact of cognitive bias on expert conclusions. The researchers also relied on testimony from corrections officer Michael Thomas, who first discovered Epstein's body. This testimony was provided only in 2021 — two years after the financier's death, while Thomas himself was under investigation for falsifying records by signing off on bed checks that never actually occurred, including on the night of Epstein's death. These data were unavailable during the initial examination in 2019.
What the new study revealed
According to Freeman, key details were missed during the official investigation: the injuries documented by the medical examiner do not match the patterns of hanging seen in suicides, and injuries that could be explained by a physical struggle or an attack were ignored. Using the photographs, Freeman created a 3D model showing that abrasions and injuries on the neck and other body parts do not fit the suicide theory. Horizontal marks on the neck, the researcher believes, point to strangulation from behind with something akin to a ligature; a piece of the torn orange bedsheets in the cell was found tied in a knot. Freeman also noted blunt force trauma to the face and left shoulder, and marks resembling fingernail scratches above the ligature marks. "Who did it? How exactly did they do it? Why were the cameras off? These are mysteries. But whether it was a suicide — that is no mystery at all," he stated.
Official stance
The official post-mortem examination was conducted by Christine Roman of the New York City Office of Chief Medical Examiner. She noted that no signs of a struggle or bruising were found, and there were no foreign particles under the fingernails; she later testified that she had no doubt it was a suicide. These conclusions had been questioned by some experts previously, yet in July 2025, the FBI confirmed in its investigation findings that Epstein had committed suicide. One month prior to his death, he had attempted suicide in his cell and was saved; a suicide note was found with the financier, which was officially published in 2026.
Report status and outlook
Freeman acknowledged that one scientific journal refused to publish his report, deeming it inappropriate to critique the official conclusions of a specific forensic medical examination. The researcher plans to resubmit his paper to another scientific journal. Thus, at present, the official suicide version remains in effect, while the findings of Freeman's team represent an alternative expert assessment that has not undergone peer review.