Experts from the IAC ISHR monitoring mission, who are observing the Rotterdam+ criminal proceedings, have noted the persistence of a negative trend they conditionally term "questionable evidence." This was reported by RBC-Ukraine, citing the mission's latest monitoring report. The document notes that a number of circumstances, taken collectively and in light of the further course of the trial, could create risks for the procedural guarantees of the parties.

'Questionable Evidence' and Risks to Article 6 of the ECHR

According to the experts, the identified trend could potentially lead to a violation of the guarantees under Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights. "Experts from the IAC ISHR monitoring mission note circumstances which, in aggregate and given the further course of the trial, could lead to a violation of the guarantees of Article 6 of the ECHR regarding the principle of equality of arms and the proper verification of evidence for which there are reasonable doubts," the report states.

What Happened at the Last Hearing

According to the report, the court continued to examine the prosecution's written evidence at the last hearing. The prosecutor additionally announced the forecasted electricity balance indicators, proposed levels for the wholesale market price, volumes of coal production, imports, and consumption, transportation costs by rail, and the estimated profitability of DTEK Group companies.

Observers state that the court repeatedly requested the prosecutor to explain not only the figures themselves but also their evidentiary value and their connection to the charges filed. The defense also attempted to clarify the content of certain materials. "During this court hearing, observers from the monitoring mission did not record the provision of exhaustive explanations by the prosecution on all questions raised by the court and the defense," IAC ISHR emphasizes. In a number of cases, according to the mission, the prosecutor referred to the fact that the connection between the materials would become clear during further examination.

Limitations for the Defense

However, the experts clarify that the recorded circumstances do not provide grounds to automatically question the relevance or authenticity of the evidence. At the same time, according to their assessment, questions regarding the content and evidentiary value of some materials remain open, and the defense has not yet had a full opportunity to systematically present its objections.

Reference to ECHR Practice

The mission referred to the practice of the European Court of Human Rights: rights guaranteed by the Convention must be "practical and effective, not theoretical or illusory" (the case of Yüksel Yalçınkaya v. Türkiye). The experts admit that delaying the defense's objections does not, in itself, violate the Convention. However, prolonged uncertainty regarding when and how these objections will be considered requires evaluation from the perspective of equality of procedural opportunities for the parties.

Chronology of the Case

Recall that the review of the Rotterdam+ case began in March 2017. Since then, the prosecutor's office has closed the proceedings five times due to the absence of a criminal offense, only to resume the investigation again.