The Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT) in London has fully dismissed a class action lawsuit against Sony, with a total value estimated at £2 billion. Following the conclusion of proceedings that began in March, the court ruled that the claimants had failed to prove that the company had violated antitrust laws. Thus, the claims that had been leveled against one of the gaming industry's biggest players for a long time were dismissed in their entirety.

The core of the claims: 'monopoly profits' from digital distribution

The claimants alleged that Sony had inflated prices for digital games by leveraging its own monopoly position. According to their narrative, the company abuses its dominant status and forces users to purchase digital games and add-ons for its console exclusively through the proprietary PlayStation Store. "Sony can set — and does set — retail prices without facing any competition in the digital content space. This allows the company to extract monopoly profits from digital distribution," the claimants' lawyers stated in court.

Sony's position: an integrated platform and competition

Sony, conversely, emphasized that it has "spent years and billions" building an integrated gaming platform that it claims benefits consumers in a competitive market. A company representative pointed out that similar distribution models are used by its competitors — Nintendo and Microsoft. In the view of Sony's counsel, the substance of the claim effectively boils down to a demand to allow third-party companies to open their own stores for PlayStation while reaping the benefits of the investments the company itself made into platform development.

Arguments on margins and brand value

Sony's lawyers also insisted that the margins the company derives from the sale of games and additional content are not excessive. They added that the lawsuit fails to account for either the company's own costs of creating and supporting the platform or the value of its brand. On these grounds, according to the defense, the accusation of price-gouging is not supported by economic data.

Context: A wave of antitrust lawsuits against tech giants in the UK

The case against Sony is the third lawsuit against a major technology company since the beginning of 2025. Analysts note that the practice of such class action lawsuits aimed at dominant technology market players is gaining momentum in the UK. The CAT's ruling on the Sony case, therefore, may serve as an important precedent for subsequent proceedings in this sphere.