At The New York Times' DealBook summit, SpaceX founder Elon Musk made harsh statements directed at Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, accusing him of lying regarding restrictions on the use of Starlink satellite communications. The outburst came against the backdrop of ongoing public disputes regarding the role of commercial and military satellite systems in frontline combat operations.
Two versions: Who is restricting what
According to Musk, the military version of the system — Starshield — is under the control of the U.S. government, while commercial Starlink connectivity is handled by his company, SpaceX. The entrepreneur claims that Zelensky seeks to use the commercial connectivity specifically for offensive strikes against Russia, despite SpaceX's refusals. "Starlink is a commercial system. And it is not intended for use as a weapon of war. It is meant to simply help people. It is meant for use as civil infrastructure. <...> Zelensky says he wants to use Starlink for offensive military operations," Musk stated. He specifically emphasized that he does not control the operation of Starshield and urged those with questions about the system's availability to reach out to the U.S. government.
Kyiv's stance: Systemic speed limitation
A week earlier, Volodymyr Zelensky made a claim that is essentially the opposite. According to him, Ukrainian military personnel recorded systemic speed limitations for Starshield when moving faster than 161 km/h, which has complicated the process of intercepting Russian drones. The President of Ukraine called these "not accidental errors, but a systemic speed limitation." Thus, the parties differ in their assessment of where the problem lies: for Kyiv, it is an artificial speed limitation on the military version of the system, and for Musk, it is an attempt to use a commercial channel for offensive purposes.
Context: Aggressor, coup, and 'incredible support'
In the same interview with journalist Andrew Ross Sorkin, Musk stated that Russia is the aggressor in the war with Ukraine. At the same time, he expressed the opinion that the U.S. government allegedly orchestrated a coup in Ukraine in 2014 to remove pro-Russian President Viktor Yanukovych. The SpaceX founder emphasized that he has helped Ukraine more than anyone else and has no dealings with Russia.
Frontline dependence on satellite communications
"Starlink, to this day, provides the foundation of communication for the Ukrainian army and for Ukraine as a whole. And if we were to turn off Starlink, the entire Ukrainian front would immediately collapse. Therefore, I think this action can only be described as incredible support for Ukraine," Musk said. In conclusion, he called for showing empathy not only to Ukrainian soldiers but also to Russian ones, who, according to him, are "forced" to go to the front.