According to The Wall Street Journal, US Presidential Special Envoy Jared Kushner and his colleague Steve Witkoff have raised the issue of granting Ukraine full NATO membership in exchange for territorial concessions to Russia during closed-door peace talks over the past months. RBC-Ukraine reports this, citing the American publication. As WSJ sources note, early last year Donald Trump himself ruled out such an option, calling it unacceptable to Moscow, but in recent months the idea has regularly featured on the agenda of American negotiators.
Two Scenarios: From Donbas to Frontline Freeze
According to WSJ, the American side is considering two possible scenarios for ending the conflict. The first involves Ukraine relinquishing control over Donbas territories—including those still held by Kyiv—in exchange for full membership in the Alliance. The second option consists of freezing hostilities along the current frontline: part of Donbas would remain under Ukrainian control, and Kyiv would receive security guarantees against a potential new Russian attack. An American official familiar with the discussions told the publication that negotiators are working through various options, but any final agreement will require the consent of both Ukraine and Russia.
Dublin, UAE, and the August Call: Where the Issue Was Raised
According to WSJ, Kushner and Witkoff have discussed the idea of Ukraine's NATO membership with European representatives on multiple occasions. Last week, the issue was raised by Kushner during a meeting with President Volodymyr Zelenskyy and EU representatives in Dublin. Additionally, this possibility was discussed at least at one meeting in the United Arab Emirates, where American special envoys communicated with representatives from Ukraine, Europe, and Russia. According to a European leader, the idea was also brought up during a phone call in August. WSJ emphasizes that Washington's readiness to discuss Alliance membership for Ukraine demonstrates how far the US is willing to go in trying to break the deadlock in negotiations.
Russia's Position: Rejection of NATO Course
The Russian side, conversely, insists that Ukraine abandon its aspirations to join NATO. During the meeting in Abu Dhabi last week, Russian representatives explicitly demanded that Kyiv drop such plans. According to WSJ, in a document circulated among participants in the negotiations, Moscow demanded that provisions regarding the aspiration to join NATO be removed from Ukraine's Constitution, that the Alliance be bound not to station its troops and military hardware in the country, and that Western countries cease arms supplies to Kyiv. Thus, the positions of the parties on the key security issue remain diametrically opposed.
Context: First Abu Dhabi Talks Since February
To recap, on November 10 and 11, the first peace talks between Ukraine, the US, and Russia since February took place in Abu Dhabi. Following the meetings, Kushner reported that the Russian side agreed to admit Europe to further peace talks on ending the war in Ukraine. In a subsequent post, he announced significant progress in understanding each side's concerns, identifying potential solutions, and drafting a roadmap for further action. Meanwhile, both the current US administration and previous American governments had previously opposed Ukraine's NATO membership, fearing it could draw the West into a direct confrontation with Moscow.