At a briefing in Berlin on November 19, 2026, following a meeting of the 'Coalition of the Willing,' President of Ukraine Volodymyr Zelenskyy stated that Kyiv and its partners do not yet have a unified understanding of how security guarantees for Ukraine modeled on NATO's Article 5 will function in practice. This was reported by RBC-Ukraine, citing the head of state, as well as the Interfax-Ukraine agency.
Context: The Berlin Summit
The statement was made during a briefing in Berlin held after the 'Coalition of the Willing' meeting. According to the Interfax-Ukraine agency, the summit was also attended by British Prime Minister Andy Burnham and German Chancellor Friedrich Merz. Zelenskyy noted that the American side, along with European partners, is ready to offer Ukraine security guarantees modeled on NATO's Article 5; however, according to him, the parties currently lack a common understanding of what exactly such guarantees will mean in practice.
'I am not sure we all understand Article 5 in the same way'
'I am not sure we all understand Article 5 in the same way,' Zelenskyy said. He explained that US representatives had discussed the issue with US President Donald Trump, the Russian side, and the European side, and, as he understood it, they are truly ready to move closer to real negotiations and results to offer Ukraine a security assurance process based on Article 5. At the same time, the head of state emphasized that he is not sure there is a common understanding of the exclusions regarding Article 5, 'as we understand them.'
The issue of American and European military presence
Zelenskyy named the presence of partner countries' military forces in Ukraine, including the potential deployment of American troops and their bases, as one of the elements of security guarantees. 'I am not advocating for or against. Of course, we would be happy if our American partners trusted their military, if their bases were in Ukraine, like in the Middle East. By the way, those countries are not NATO members. But there are certain bases there,' the president noted. He added that he currently has no answer as to whether the guarantees will include the presence of American and European military forces: 'Forces of the United States and European partners. Troops, bases. Without this, I am not sure it is Article 4, Article 5, etc.'
The main issue — concrete actions during a renewed aggression
According to Zelenskyy, the main question is the concrete actions of allies in the event of a renewed Russian attack. 'Not if, forgive my skepticism, but when they try to do it again. What will they do?' asked the head of state, emphasizing that Ukraine must understand in advance exactly how partners will react to aggression. He also noted that Ukraine needs explanations of how Article 5-style guarantees will work without NATO membership: 'Okay, Article 5, but without NATO. Explain to us what that means.'
Guarantees for investors and returning citizens
Zelenskyy emphasized that clear answers are needed not only by partner governments but also by society, citizens, and potential investors. 'Everyone wants to invest in Ukraine. [...] People are strong, they have proven it. Nine million people — we hope they will return. And all these people need clear answers,' the president stated, referring to the hope for the return of nine million Ukrainians currently abroad.
The American position
On the same day, US Special Envoy Jared Kushner stated that Russia had agreed to the concept of security guarantees for Ukraine analogous to NATO Article 5. According to him, American negotiators have managed to make significant progress in discussing security guarantees, and according to Kushner's assessment, Russia is already accepting this model. Thus, the American side's statement about progress and Zelenskyy's words about the lack of a common understanding of practical details form a picture in which the conceptual framework is discussed as achieved, while its specific content remains the subject of further negotiations.