Russia has once again demanded that the United States and its allies rule out the possibility of Ukraine joining NATO. According to the Associated Press, cited by RBC-Ukraine, the Kremlin has returned to the positions Moscow voiced back in late 2021—shortly before launching its full-scale invasion.
A Return to 2021 Demands
Moscow is insisting on a complete overhaul of Europe's security architecture: Ukraine must remain outside the North Atlantic Alliance, and Western troops and weapons must not be deployed on its territory. These exact formulations were contained in draft agreements that Russia handed to the US and NATO in December 2021. At the time, key demands included the alliance renouncing further expansion (including Ukraine and Georgia), a ban on deploying Western military forces in former Soviet republics, the withdrawal of NATO troops from Central and Eastern Europe to their 1997 positions, and restrictions on drills and patrolling near Russian borders. The West rejected these conditions, and Vladimir Putin later cited the refusal to heed Moscow's stance as one of the reasons for the invasion.
Talks in Moscow: Witkoff and Kushner
After years of war, the Kremlin has seen an opportunity to return to its long-standing demands within the framework of negotiations involving the US. The Russian leader discussed security issues with American representatives Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner during their visit to Moscow on November 12. According to Putin's foreign policy adviser Yury Ushakov, during these talks the Russian president recalled the 2021 proposals and stated that Moscow intends to supplement them with new demands.
Europe Objects: Kallas's Warning
In Kyiv and European capitals, this initiative is causing concern. EU leaders fear that Putin could persuade US President Donald Trump to support peace agreement terms that would weaken Ukraine and threaten the security of the entire continent. European top diplomat Kaja Kallas warned against discussing Russian demands regarding future security architecture before a ceasefire: «If we start discussing what Russia demands on security, we will essentially fall into the traps it is setting for us».
The US Position and Risks for Kyiv
The American side, in turn, has stated its readiness to discuss security guarantees for Ukraine comparable to those operating within NATO. According to Jared Kushner, Trump aims to conclude an agreement with Europe's participation rather than imposing it unilaterally. Nevertheless, Kyiv believes that any discussions of «broad European security issues» initiated by Moscow create risks for Ukraine's sovereignty.
Expert Assessment
Analysts believe Moscow may use the negotiation process to extract concessions from the West and deepen divisions among European countries. At the same time, they argue that Russia remains prepared to continue the war if negotiations do not yield the expected results. Thus, the return to the 2021 demands is perceived as an attempt to cement at the diplomatic level what Moscow failed to achieve previously.