On November 14, a U.S. District Judge in the Northern District of California denied a joint motion by Samsung, SK Hynix, and Micron to dismiss a class-action lawsuit accusing the companies of intentionally restricting DRAM memory supplies. The judge ruled that the complaint contains sufficient allegations of an agreement violating Section 1 of the Sherman Act, a key U.S. antitrust statute. As a result, the case is not dismissed at the outset but will proceed toward full litigation: the defendants have until December 7 to respond to the complaint, and the first scheduling conference is set for January 12, 2027.

The Substance of Allegations: Coordinated Shift to AI Memory

The lawsuit was filed in June by a group of 17 consumers and small business owners, including small PC sales and repair shops. According to the document, the three companies—which accounted for more than 91% of global DRAM revenue in the third quarter of 2025, according to the plaintiffs—coordinated production cuts beginning in late 2022. It is alleged that they diverted production capacity to HBM memory, which is critical for AI accelerators, resulting in a 697% price hike for standard DRAM over 18 months. Note: this is a preliminary stage, and none of these allegations have been proven in court yet.

Why the Judge Considered the Lawsuit New, Not Repetitive

The defendants argued that the current lawsuit is a repetition of a previously dismissed case regarding supply cuts during 2016–2018, which was closed by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in 2022. The judge disagreed, pointing to new circumstances: the execution of long-term HBM supply contracts, the alleged abandonment of long-term agreements with standard DRAM buyers by Samsung and SK Hynix, Micron's discontinuation of the Crucial brand, and the implementation of nearly identical customer screening procedures by all three companies in January 2026. The judge even addressed the “hawks” comparison proposed by the defendants, noting that the described actions resemble a “formation of hawks” — implying a coordinated, rather than independent, flight.

The Shadow of the 1998–2002 Precedent

The judge also deemed it appropriate to consider the DRAM market cartel precedent that existed between 1998 and 2002. At that time, Samsung and SK Hynix were fined, while Micron received immunity from prosecution after reaching a plea deal. This historical episode, according to the plaintiffs, reinforces their argument that the memory market has already faced coordinated behavior by major players. The plaintiffs are seeking class certification, injunctive relief, and triple damages.

What This Means for Prices and the Market

The new lawsuit itself will not lead to an increase in physical chip production volumes. Meanwhile, the CEO of SK Hynix predicts that memory shortages will persist until 2030, so do not expect a quick price drop in the near future. For consumers and small businesses whose component costs have already risen, the outcome of this case could set a precedent in disputes over memory market pricing, though the path to a final judgment is long and uncertain.